Up to 40% Off summer bundles

Free domestic shipping orders over $65
Cart 0
Your order qualifies for free shipping! You are $65 away from FREE shipping
No more products available for purchase

Pair with
A box and packet of Shop FlavCity Sleep Support Vitamin Gel Pack in purple packaging, a vanilla mint melatonin gel with phytomelatonin and L-tryptophan, no added sugar, seed oils, or fillers; supports better sleep.

Sleep Support Vitamin Gel Pack

$39.99

A box and pouch of Shop FlavCity Multivitamin Gel Pack in Orange Mango, delivering 33 essential vitamins for immune support. No added sugar, seed oils, or fillers. Shown on a white background.

Multivitamin Gel Pack

$39.99

A Shop FlavCity Immune Support Vitamin Gel Pack with orange flavor features vitamins C, D3, and zinc for antioxidant protection. The packaging displays vibrant orange slice graphics and branding consistent with the box.

Immune Support Vitamin Gel Pack

$39.99

Shop FlavCity C-Ya Later! Vitamin C

C-Ya Later! Vitamin C

$29.99

Shop FlavCity Lemon Lime Electrolyte Mix

Lemon Lime Electrolyte Mix

$44.99

Subtotal Free
Shipping & taxes calculated at checkout

Your Cart is Empty

Stock up on what your body
actually needs.

Two bags of Flavory All-in-One Protein Smoothie Powder, one in Vanilla flavor and the other Chocolate Peanut Butter, both displaying “25g protein” and “Made with Grass-Fed Whey” on the front.
Protein Smoothies
Shop FlavCity Try-It Kit: Electrolytes
Electrolytes
Five bottles of supplements and vitamins, including womens and mens multivitamin gummies, sleep support gummies, vitamin C, and a Triple Threat bottle, are arranged diagonally against a white background.
Vitamins
Shop ALL
Peanut Butter Protein Pies.

Peanut Butter Protein Pies

Mar 17, 2025

jump to recipe

These Peanut Butter Protein Pies are the perfect snack-sized indulgence and require no baking. They’re loaded with nutrition because we use a triple dose of protein to make the filling; FlavCity Vanilla Cream Protein Smoothie, peanut butter powder, and Greek yogurt. Simple Mills Chocolate Sweet Thins make for a delicious, buttery but grain-free crust. And the drizzle of melted chocolate over the top literally takes these pies ‘over the top!’ You gotta try them!

Makes 9 Servings

Category

Dessert, Snacks

Prep time

10 Minutes

chill time

180 Minutes

Ingredients

Topping

Directions

  • In a food processor, add the sweet thin crackers and the melted butter,
    and pulse until you get a sandy texture. Evenly distribute the crust
    mixture among 9 cups in a silicone muffin mold. Gently press down the
    mixture to create the crust at the bottom of each cup.
  • In a
    bowl mix together the Greek yogurt, FlavCity Vanilla Cream Protein
    Smoothie, and peanut butter powder until it’s well combined.
  • Distribute
    the yogurt mixture evenly among the 9 crusts, making sure to use all of
    the mix. Then pop the muffin mold into the freezer for about 3-4 hours
    to let the pies set.
  • Melt the chocolate using a double boiler, then remove the pies
    from the muffin mold and drizzle the melted chocolate over the top of
    each pie and enjoy!
  • Store any leftovers in the freezer. Let them sit out for a few minutes when you’re ready to enjoy them again.

NOTE: If using FlavCity plant-based protein smoothie, be sure to double the amount to 3 scoops.